When you purchase a new or used vehicle, you expect it to be safe, reliable, and worth your investment. But if your car ends up spending more time at the repair shop than on the road, you might start hearing about something called the Lemon Law.
While Lemon Laws are designed to protect consumers, there are many misunderstandings about how they work — and these misconceptions can prevent people from getting the help they deserve.
Let’s clear up some of the most common myths about Lemon Law and set the record straight.
Misconception #1: Lemon Law Only Applies to New Cars
The Truth:
While Lemon Laws were originally created to protect buyers of new vehicles, many states now extend protections to used cars, especially if they are still under warranty.
In some cases, even leased vehicles and certified pre-owned cars may qualify under Lemon Law provisions or related consumer protection laws.
Tip:
Always check your state’s specific Lemon Law and warranty protections for both new and used vehicles.
Misconception #2: A Car Has to Be Completely Broken to Qualify
The Truth:
Your car doesn’t have to be completely inoperable to be considered a lemon.
If a defect substantially impairs the vehicle’s use, safety, or value — such as a recurring brake failure, engine problems, or electrical issues — it could qualify, even if the car still runs.
Tip:
It’s about the severity and impact of the defect, not whether the car still moves.
Misconception #3: You Must Allow Unlimited Repair Attempts
The Truth:
You are not required to give the manufacturer or dealership unlimited chances to fix your car.
Most states define a “reasonable number of repair attempts” — often between two to four — depending on the seriousness of the defect.
Tip:
If the problem persists after multiple repair attempts, or your car is out of service for an extended period (usually 30+ days), you likely have a valid Lemon Law claim.
Misconception #4: Lemon Law Claims Are Too Complicated to Win
The Truth:
While the process does involve paperwork, timelines, and legal procedures, an experienced Lemon Law attorney can handle the complexities for you.
Many attorneys work on a contingency fee basis — meaning you don’t pay unless you win — and in many cases, the manufacturer has to cover your legal fees if you prevail.
Tip:
Don’t let fear of the process discourage you from asserting your rights.
Misconception #5: Accepting a Repair Void Your Lemon Law Rights
The Truth:
Simply agreeing to repairs does not waive your Lemon Law rights.
In fact, giving the manufacturer a reasonable chance to fix the problem is often a necessary step to strengthen your case.
Tip:
Keep detailed records of all repair attempts, including work orders, receipts, and communications with the dealer or manufacturer.
Misconception #6: You Must Settle for Whatever the Dealer Offers
The Truth:
Dealers or manufacturers may offer you low-ball settlements, such as minor cash reimbursements or trade-ins.
You are not obligated to accept an unfair offer if your vehicle qualifies as a lemon.
You may be entitled to a full refund, replacement vehicle, or a significantly better settlement through legal action.
Tip:
Consult with a Lemon Law attorney before accepting any offers.
Conclusion: Know the Facts, Protect Your Rights
Misunderstandings about Lemon Law can cause many consumers to miss out on the protections they deserve.
The truth is simple: If your car has a serious defect that the manufacturer can’t fix within a reasonable time, you have rights — and the law is on your side.